Site Map | Search | Terms & Conditions - PAIA
Company Profile | Products | Support | Contact Us | Community
...facilitating access to information
Legal | Electronic Publications | Online Reference | Collection Management | Library Systems | Cataloguing | Interlending | Client Access
HomeProductsElectronic Publications (Online Journals) Abstract Information
JournalsElectronic Publishing
Abstract Info
Latest issues added
More on this service
Subscription FAQ

Abstract Information

The 'inevitability' of same-sex marriage in South Africa's post-Apartheid state

  • Journal Title: South African Journal on Human Rights : Sexuality and the Law : Special Issue
  • Volume: Volume 23
  • Issue:  Issue 3
  • Publication Date: 2007
  • Pages: 432  - 465
  • Authors:  Pierre De Vos;
  • ISSN: 02587203
  • Abstract:  This article argues that the adoption of the Civil Union Act, extending marriage rights to same-sex couples, does not represent the inevitable and triumphant victory of a long legal and political struggle for the emancipation of gay men and lesbians in South Africa. A combination of luck, wise strategic leadership and fortitude eventually led to the adoption of full marriage rights for same-sex couples. The article traces the roots of this legal and political victory back to the debates about the inclusion of the sexual orientation clause in the South African Constitution and points to the importance of the distinct (conservative) legal strategy employed by the National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality in achieving full partnership rights for all. The initial jurisprudence developed by the Constitutional Court created the basis for later legal victories and brought along judges who might have had some misgivings about the extension of marriage rights to same-sex couples had the issue arisen earlier on. The Constitutional Court's judgment in Fourie left very little room for Parliament to manoeuvre because it emphasised the symbolic value of marriage and confirmed that a 'separate but equal' partnership law for same-sex couples would not pass constitutional muster. However, this important legal victory will not have any direct and immediate bearing on the lives of many gay men and lesbians in South Africa as they face social, cultural and economic hardship in ways that cannot be easily addressed through the legal reform of partnership laws. The improvement of the lives of ordinary gay men and lesbians will go hand in hand with changes in societal attitudes towards minority sexualities, which to a large extent will be dependent on grassroots activism and organisation. Because the battle for full marriage rights was a well directed, elite-based legal battle, it failed to build a sustainable, vibrant, grassroots movement to take on this task but the symbolic space created by the same-sex marriage reform may well begin to allow for the fostering of such a movement and thus for true emancipation of gay men and lesbians.
  • Read this article

For subscription and additional information please contact us on:

  • Tel: +27 12 643-9500
  • email:
  • alternatively you can complete this form and one of our portfolio managers will contact you!

Sabinet Online Ltd. is Proudly South AfricanCompany Profile | Products | Support | Contact Us | Community
P O Box 9785 Centurion 0046 | | 0800 11 85 95
Copyright © Sabinet Online Ltd 2008. All Rights Reserved. Terms & Conditions. PAIA.